Close Window close window
Please login to view your impounmdments!
Skip Navigation
Image of the Coal Impoundment LIS Location and Information System logo.
Button that links to the Login page.   Button that links to the My Impoundments page.
 
Button that links to the Locate Impoundment page.
Home About the Project Partners Contact Us News Events Help
• About Impoundments
What Are They? Classes Facts Spills/Historical Info
• Reference Best Practices Legal Multimedia Glossary Links
• Advancements General Applications Full Scale Applications Prototype Technologies Alternatives Research & Development Partnership Opportunities
Coal Impoundment Survey
A survey concerning the safety of coal impoundments was conducted in Wyoming and Mingo counties in West Virginia. The survey teams contacted 605 homes, and 407 homes accepted the survey. Of those that agreed to participate, 256 returned completed surveys.

Key results in the survey are:

  • Residents are generally satisfied with their quality of life. Nearly 4 out of 10 residents (37 percent) reported the overall quality of life in their community as “good” to “very good.”
  • Crime/Drugs, unemployment, health problems and sewage were all rated the principal “serious problems” among area residents. Economic growth also remains an overriding and principal issue among residents, as 61 percent of those surveyed cited economic growth as a serious problem facing their communities.
  • Drinking water is a problem. Twenty-nine percent of survey respondents rated the quality of the drinking water in their community as a serious problem. Though certainly
    not as striking as 8 out of 10 citizens in Martin County, Ky., who rated drinking water as a serious issue after the 2000 spill there, this percentage seems to reflect a high overall concern with drinking water.
  • Households with employment or business ties to coal mining were more likely to agree (53 percent) or strongly agree (33 percent) that the coal industry provides jobs and economic opportunity to local people. Whereas 88 percent of those linked to the industry acknowledged the benefits associated with coal mining on the local economy, only 56 percent (40 percent agree, 16 percent strongly agree) of those with no direct ties to the industry identified local economic benefits associated with coal-mining activities.
  • The public is reluctant to concede that the possible economic benefits of impoundments outweigh their costs. Of households with ties to the coal industry, 43 percent either disagreed or strongly disagreed that the economic benefits associated with coal and coal waste impoundments outweigh the risks. Likewise, among households with no direct links to the coal industry, 45 percent either disagreed or strongly disagreed with this assertion.
  • Coal waste impoundments are a high-hazard, high consequence technology. A majority (53 percent) of households with ties to the coal industry either agreed or strongly agreed that an impoundment break would result in certain death, whereas 61 percent of households with no ties to the industry agreed or strongly agreed with that statement. Moreover, an equal 60 percent of households (both with ties to the coal industry and without ties) either agreed or strongly agreed that an impoundment breakthrough would kill many people at one time.
  • Impoundment safety and stability remain questionable. Households with ties to the coal industry and households with no ties shared similar views on this issue. Seventy percent of households with ties, and 73 percent of households without ties, either strongly disagreed or disagreed or just didn’t know about the overall stability of the impoundment in their community. Overall, respondents in 7 out of 10 homes believe that there is some possibility that the impoundment in their community might rupture in the future.
  • When it comes to trust, county emergency responders come first. When asked whom they trusted, households ranked county emergency responders first, followed by the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA), state agencies, and coal companies. Households with ties to the coal industry were slightly more likely to trust and concede authority to coal companies, MSHA and state agencies than other households.
Image of an arrow. Read the entire Press Release
Image of an arrow. 2004-2005 Annual Report (PDF)
 Information
Image of an arrow. Water Quality Study
Image of an arrow. Pineville Town Meeting
Image of an arrow. Results: Coal Impoundment Survey
Image of an arrow. More Impoundment News
 Past Spills Information
Image of an arrow. Buffalo Creek Flood
Image of an arrow. Martin County Flood
 Locate an Impoundment
Image of an arrow. Interactive Mapping
Image of an arrow. List Impoundments
Image of an arrow. Keyword Search
 
Button that links to the Learn More About Impoundments page. Button that links to the Coal Impoundment home page.